Closed now.

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Too early?



Do you feel that Christmas celebrations start too early?
There was quite a discussion on the West Country news after the lights in Plymouth were switched on......on November 13th. 
Yes, there were some who thought it added to the jollity of the season.
But many people felt it was all too soon and that by Christmas any 'magic' had gone.

I think it is more restrained in Europe. When we lived in France there were very few decorations until well into December. Then the village lights would be switched on, some Christmas trees would appear in the supermarkets, but there wasn't the same razzmatazz as we have in England.

Our stays in Austria during the Christmas period were lovely, and we so enjoyed the Christmas markets, where there were handmade and natural goods for sale.
The only lights were white ones, twinkling through the trees in the squares.


What do you think? 
Should we just accept that things may start earlier each year, or should we hope that the real meaning of Christmas might come across. In December.

27 comments:

  1. Being a Bah Humbug sort of person I feel that it is profit and commercialisation that seem to have taken over from the original innocent celebration of the season. Who are these people who spend hundreds of pounds on gifts for each other often money they haven;t got whilst there are others living on the streets in utter poverty? I do hope you are right about the true spirit and meaning coming across but I am not too optimistic! I loved the fact that in France there were few cards to be bought and nothing at all Christmasy until well into December.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I quite like the getting ready early for Christmas. I used to be a vicar and if I hadn't got my personal Christmas (cards, presents, letters) sorted out by this time they wouldn't get sorted. I had to be ready for Christmas professionally too and did as mush as possible before December began so that if there were problems (eg tragedy in the parish, other clergy being taken ill) I had time and energy to deal with them. I love the street decorations too, but I want the authorities to have workmen available for snow clearing, gritting, flood protection etc and so they need to have the frilly bits done in good time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like getting ready ahead of time for Christmas - making gifts, addressing cards and such - and I also like waiting until December to decorate. I don't mind the lights and decorations in the stores as I can choose to go there or not (other than for groceries). A few stores in our town got bad press for holding "Remembrance Day Sales." Rightly so.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love Christmas
    If anyone read my blog in the past they might remember trees in every room
    Dec,. 1st it happens
    O gave away to my G, grandchildren all my decorations so they could have a big celebration of the event
    I have all new stuff this year

    ReplyDelete
  5. I totally understand public Christmas things from mid November onwards, but I do wish that the shops would wait until a bit later than they do. If they could hold off until at least the start of November that would be nice. I saw Christmas chocolate and so on appearing in September which seemed rather soon to me! xx

    ReplyDelete
  6. In the States it's even worse. The retail stores start putting out Christmas decorations and Christmas items for sale in October. I agree it's way too early.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It wasn't this way when I was a child,and I preferred it that way.
    Jane x

    ReplyDelete
  8. I say let's wait until December. I love the magic but do get tired of all the commercialism. Would like to see more emphasis on the original reason for the celebration - our Lord

    ReplyDelete
  9. My opinions are sort of a mixed bag -- when my children were small my shopping was done well in advance because I don't like chaos or crowds. However, in the US we have another major holiday between Halloween and Christmas which is sort of a buffer. When I was growing up, Christmas here didn't start until after Thanksgiving. Things have changed a bit over the years and now I think it is more of an economic thing that Christmas basically starts right after Halloween. In our house, however, it doesn't. We make time for Thanksgiving because we feel it is important to set aside that time for just that -- giving thanks. However, Thanksgiving weekend is a long weekend (4 days) and after the meals is cooked and consumed, the leftovers packed away Christmas starts. We have a ceramic Christmas village that is the center of all our decor -- sometimes a tree, sometimes not -- all sorts of things set around but then, we are quiet for Advent. Each Sunday around our table we light the Advent wreath and we study the Word of the Day and we try our best to remember what the meaning of Christmas really is.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I do shop early, but other than that I pretty much ignore the store, the music, the decorations until December.
    We lived in Germany for many years and I loved the Christmas Markets

    ReplyDelete
  11. I wholeheartedly agree!
    The only sign of Christmas in France when we left on Nov 1st was a few piles of chocolate boxes in the supermarkets.
    As soon as we got home we found the Christmas extravaganza in full swing everywhere and we're sick of it already!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I wish we could all wait until nearer the day. I seem to reach saturation point before mid-December! There are houses near us with their Christmas trees up in the windows already!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I don't like decorations until well into December - the usual huge tree appeared in the town centre this weekend, Pudsey the dog switched on the lights in the next nearest town, I would like it all to wait a bit! I also can't get along with too many decorations, less is more - but hubby on the other hand likes complete overload on decorations!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I was just thinking this morning that I might start a bit earlier with my Christmas decorating. I'm always more in the mood now than I am as the season progresses. I like all the Christmas decor in the stores, but I DO get tired of the holiday commercials on television.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree with those of your readers who like to get a jump on the preparations like Christmas cards and gifts. I love sending the cards, but addressing them takes time, so I try to have them sorted by the middle of November. Then I can relax - do some baking - attend some of the many wonderful choral offerings in our city, and not feel rushed or stressed.

    I do object though to being deluged with Christmas music in the stores, before I've even had time to buy my Halloween candy!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hello Elizabeth,

    I love the December option, to be honest. At home we first have the feast of St. Nicolaas (Dec. 5th) and only after that the Christmas decorations come out etc. In the garden centres etc. it's very different and the kids love it, but I prefer 'a certain time for everything' ;)

    Have a nice week & love, Carolien

    ReplyDelete
  17. It's way too early here. There are already live Christmas trees for sale at some stores. The commercialization of Christmas...I'm not for it.
    God bless and enjoy your week!
    Anne ♥

    ReplyDelete
  18. I noticed the Christmas lights in Saint-Brieuc have been up for some weeks already, but they are not lit... I think they won't be before Advent.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Too early. Some of the stores have a few decorations, but the big lights aren't up yet. The lights at Lincoln Center will be turned on the Monday after Thanksgiving.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Here in Finland Christmas time has also begun. Shops are full on decorations and Christmas songs plays everywhere. Too soon, I agree.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I guess I have to say that yes, from a consumer point of view we become bombarded quite early here in the States. But from the point of view of the workers needing the extra hours to make ends meet, It is necessary. I don't let the decorations and such get to me anymore. Instead I enjoy the festivities and give thanks to our God that we are all well to enjoy them :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. The Christmas season creeps in. We have huge craft store chain that rushes the seasons and if you don't by early, then by the time you are really in the mood to shop and decorate for the holiday, all the good stuff is gone. This store puts Christmas stuff out as early as October pre-Halloween. I saw a sign at a local mall yesterday advertising that it would be open Thanksgiving evening. Really? The next day, generally is a holiday, too, so stores are open and it has become known as Black Friday when all of the retailers offer deals. People will camp out for days in the parking lot to be there when the doors open on Black Friday. Crazy.

    My letter is off to Anke.

    ReplyDelete
  23. No lights in our area yet!
    I try to avoid the too~early commercial side by simply not going into town very much! But I do like a drive round the city at night time just before Christmas; we have a lot of cobbled alleyways and old buildings in the city centre - it looks magical lit for Christmas.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I think it starts way too early here in the US. That being said, I admit to enjoying shopping in the craft store today for Christmas ornaments. Everything was so pretty! But still...I don't like decorating until in December. Although, Advent starts the Sunday after Thanksgiving and that is still Nov.

    ReplyDelete
  25. The first Sunday of Advent is 30th November which is when I make my Advent wreath and place it on the table.
    We usually buy our tree in the second week of December.
    I love the traditions, songs and Hymns of Christmas but not the commercial side of things.
    For me it's about reflecting on the meaning and reason behind Christmas.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hi Barbara, I am just catching up on posts and this is such an interesting topic. I am usually one of those people who insists that the decorating for Christmas not start until after Thanksgiving, and yet, I am starting very early this year! My daughter who lives in another state, and her dear husband will be here for Thanksgiving but not for Christmas, so our family is planning to exchange gifts and celebrate early with them. Obviously we all have differing circumstances and sometimes we have to celebrate when we have our loved ones near rather than on the exact date. I also think that with the work that decorating takes I want to enjoy it as long as possible, because after Christmas is over I am always anxious to take it down and start the new year fresh. It's really just personal preference, but I love the lights and warmth of Christmas decorating. What is REALLY too early is the advertising and commercial aspect of Christmas.

    ReplyDelete

I love to read your comments. Thank you for visiting me.