Some of you in the UK may have seen a report about a school teacher who thought up a strange and different way to teach his children about problem solving.
An 'alien egg'was discovered in the school grounds, with all the razzmatazz surrounding it...men in protective clothing, Geiger counters etc.
Children were asked to question where the egg might have come from, to draw pictures and to write essays.
Well, as a stunt it failed.
The children were apparently so traumatised and frightened that angry parents stepped in, saying their children were too frightened to go to school. (Really??!)
It emerges that other schools have tried to engage flagging interest by putting on stunts such as a fake kidnapping of a member of staff, the 'killing' of a teacher, an assault on a staff member, a spaceship arriving..
The school heads have defended these 'larks' by saying what an impact they had on the childrens writing. I wonder what impact they had on the sensitive little ones who find it difficult enough to relate to school.
The other side of the impact seemed to involve children left in floods of tears, vomiting with shock and terror, and children left sobbing in fear.
As an ex teacher, and one who went through school days without any of that nonsense, I can only wonder why it is necessary to 'engage' the sometimes jaded attention of classes in such a manner.
For me a good teacher who shows real interest in students, who can have fun with them without resorting to this sort of playacting, is worth far more than all this wackiness.
What's next, I wonder? A false news report of the Queen's kidnapping? A fake TV broadcast of the world coming to an end?
What do you think?

The general idea could perhaps be a good one but does it have to be quite so frightening? On one hand some of the children will be used to seeing scary stuff on the TV or in computer games and so on but there will always be the more sensitive ones who have good imaginations for whom it will backfire. As you say why do teachers have to resort to such stunts to get the children to be interested in their work.
ReplyDeleteHow impressive that those teachers are trying so hard, but if only they were good at engaging with their class and had a good relationship, then I think these traumatic imaginary scenarios would not be necessary, children are naturally curious so with todays huge range of technology I would have thought there is plenty of scope to fire their imaginations when delivered by someone who holds their attention and has 'presence'.
ReplyDeleteI did not know that you were a teacher. Me, too. Children have a natural curiosity, even moody teens. Here in the US, educators prodded by government are so bent on test scores that all imagination in teaching as been all but destroyed. As an English teacher, I found that reading inspired the best writing.
ReplyDeleteOne of my favourite lessons when I was about 8, came from the class being led out of the classroom by a band of 'gypsies', behind the teacher's back. We had such an adventure!
ReplyDeleteJane x
You are not an ex-teacher, you are a former teacher. You'll always be a teacher.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. We should never compete with the entertainment industry. It's a greed-based phenomena. We should love kids and talk to them about all the interesting features of the world God gave us. We should teach them the benefit of wisdom. I've found that kids are not impressed with this crazy sort of thing. They want real because they are real.
There must be ways to engage children, without resorting to 'crime' or 'violence' or 'trauma'. Not being a teacher (in any sense of the word), I would find it difficult, but real teachers - by that I mean those who teach because they love to share knowledge and inspire young people - should be ABLE to come up with something to stir the imagination.
ReplyDeleteHow is it firing up imagination by making the children think that something is 'real'? Children naturally have amazing imaginations.
ReplyDeleteI remember some chinese lanterns flying over our house one evening. We had not seen them before and as we stopped and watched them wondering, I jokingly said, "It's aliens". Well, immediately both my children ran in the house screaming hysterically and sobbing uncontrollably. It took me ages to calm them down, apologise and to explain I was joking.
No, children do not need their imaginations firing up, they have enough of their own, and we need to remember how sensitive they are and how they trust the words of adults implicitly when they are young. It can be a dangerous advantage to have and we must be so careful what we say and teach our children. xx
Sensation?! Why is everyone, teachers included, looking to be "sensational"? I agree with you. We had none of this nonsense when I was in grade school and we LEARNED. We certainly did NOT have all these side trips to zoos, museums, etc. We learned! And we are the smartest generation ever. Today we are raising kids to be technologically "smart" at the expense of them not being able to "relate" to each because of the social media. Oooooh, don't get me started. I may never stop. I'm fining it abhorrent. They can't even speak well/properly! I have many friends who are college graduates and still say "Him and Me"! Teach them the basics and forget the "nonsense." They learn that and how to "cope" as they go through life. Okay, ya got me on a rant again, sugar! Sorry. I'll email privately later.
ReplyDeletexoxo to you and Malcolm,
Connie
Hi Elizabeth! Alien eggs huh. Well, if there weren't any people dressed up in funny costumes or police, it might have been a fun exercise. I think this teacher went a bit overboard.
ReplyDeleteI think your point about sensitive children is well taken. My son would have loved this. My daughter would be shaking in her shoes. We do need to be aware of ALL children's personalities.
A little boredom is not fatal. It actually can birth some really great imaginations. I think we can trust that the children will be okay with that!
Blessings,
Ceil
Enough piffle without creating more
ReplyDeleteNow more interesting stuff
I bought about 10 white plants yesterday to start a white border.
A clematis , prince George . Must be a new one .
A white hydrangea , raining so too wet to go out and read the label.
Achilea raining too fast to go and look for correct spelling ,
Phlox x2
White daisy
White pinks
Penstamon,and a few small front of border plants
I iike to change the borders about every 4 years
.
Children are so very ready to 'engage' that a good teacher doesn't need to pull such stunts. It's really very silly - and lazy too, I think.
ReplyDeleteI once heard a presentation by a young woman who taught in the school in Ecuador. She held up a photo of a baby and told everyone this was her baby and how much she missed her and how she had put the baby up for adoption because of an teenage pregnancy, etc, etc. She talked about the disadvantages of her situation and went on for quite awhile, finally ending with, "well, that really wasn't my baby and I didn't have a teenage pregnancy."
ReplyDeleteI felt very deceived as her presentation was very emotionally engaging. A good teacher doesn't need to resort to such deceit in order to engage students.
Why do we need to stimulate their imagination with such 'over the top' stunts?
ReplyDeleteA simple lesson, well taught, can spark an amazing amount of creative writing - about REAL things, describing what has actually happened, and how people felt.
One of my best ever lessons involved a box containing a scruffy teddy bear, a pair of lace gloves, a few [predecimal coins] and a photo showing a 1940s bride with a groom in soldier's uniform. The box was labelled 'found on a bomb site' and the children were asked to write a story. The stuff they came up with was fabulous- not an alien, ray gun, iPad or X-box anywhere!! And nobody was scared either.