Closed now.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Kindle versus book


I've had a Kindle e-reader for over a year now, and originally bought it because we were going to be in Austria for two weeks. I knew there wasn't much likelihood of getting English books there, so loaded up the reader and found it just what I needed.




But...do I love it in the same way as I love a book?
Never.
When I have a 'real' book I start at the beginning. I read the title page. I look at the date of the book. I flick to the back to read something about the author. I hold it in my hands, feeling the weight of the words, words that I'm going to read, chapters that I can turn back to to check what I might have missed. If it's a new book it has a certain smell...of new book, waiting to be discovered.


A Kindle is for convenience. I'm grateful to have one.
But it also needs charging at the most inconvenient moment. 
A book just is.
There is no contest for me.
What do you think?

18 comments:

  1. I love books. I like to hold them in my hands. I like to go to the library or bookstore and look on the shelves for a new book to check out or buy. Hubby has a Kindle but even he still goes back to his favorite books to re read. I guess you can tell where I stand :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, my Kindle is great for holidays and for obtaining sample reads of books before committing to them but it just doesn't have the promise a new book brings, I recently downloaded a cookery book and felt totally un-inspired,

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't have a Kindle although friends tell me how wonderful they are but I can't imagine one being the same as a real book - the differences in the thickness and weight, the type of paper used, the general feel of the thing - no a Kindle is not on my list of things I might like to have although I can see the advantages when traveling.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was an interesting post. I think I shall need a Kindle soon so I can change the font. But I do love books. For hols I think they're great as Steve can read half a dozen books or so on holiday - makes luggage very heavy - lol :)
    L.x.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A real book for me! I have Mrs Kindle for PC on my computer and can get Kindle books on that, (Iusually download pattern books) but I find this very frustrationg - you can't easily print out a pattern and often the pages are in some weird order with not as many pictures as the 'real' book! I'm not downloading any more!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love reading, just reading. And it actually doesn't matter what I'm reading. One thing about an e-reader - I can go to the library, and never leave home. Not sure if that's a good thing or not!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I clearly agree. I know that technology has its place and for college students electronic readers are replacing books and I understand why, but I like books, musty, tattered, yellowed books. Not better way to read Jane Austin or Emily Bronte than from an old engraved, tattered book handed down from grandma to little girl.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree. I have a Nook and I bought it so that I could use it as a tablet and have a book and computer access with me. I also bought it to sort of reduce my book collection as I have run out of room but, no, an e-reader will never take the place of a book. Ever.

    ReplyDelete
  9. It has to be a book.Absolutely!
    Jane x

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have a Kindle, but I just love a book! :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I love my Kindle, use it every day, but part of that is because I can go on-line with it. Nothing will ever completely take the place of a book in my hand.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm a book person!! If I'm going on a trip, I just pack a book. I also read the introduction, copy dates, the entire book from front to back! I'm reading a reproduction of a very old book right now, and it has a beautiful cover that I run my hand over every time I pick it up. :-) I'm a collector and have a pretty good size library.:-) My daughter has a Kindle which she uses for college text books which are VERY expensive, but a lot less on a Kindle ~ so that helps there. But to me, nothing can replace a real book!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm all for books! I don't own an e-reader, although I won't discount getting one at some point - for travel, perhaps.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I agree with you. I love books -- the feel, the texture, the look of the words on the page, the smell, the colours of the covers....No electronic device can replace all that. Besides, with an e-reader or Kindle or a Nook, I woiuldn't be able to use the lovely bookmark my sister-in-law needlepointed for me! xoxox

    ReplyDelete
  15. It seems that most people who own an e-reader,(I have a Kobo)love the convenience but always prefer a book. I used to work in a used book shop and loved the smell of the books. My husband got an e-reader and much preferred it, yet I vowed I would never own one! Never say never Julie!! I did succumb and they definitely have their uses, but give me a good book any day. It is much nicer to hold. I'm off to bed for a bit of reading (and this time it is a "real" book!) By the way Elizabeth, I tried your roasted tomatoes and they were delicious. We mixed them with chick peas and cottage cheese for lunch.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I'm a book girl through and through... Though I have a bit of a problem finding space for all the ones I have!

    ReplyDelete

I love to read your comments. Thank you for visiting me.