Closed now.

Saturday, November 10, 2007

November 11th


It's strange in France not to see people wearing poppies this week. We see them on Television, but not in real life..unless the person is English. Explaining the poppy symbol to the French is interesting, as the fields of Flanders don't seem to have the same meaning. Their flower for this day is the Bleuet, or cornflower, and they wear a little brooch or flag on the day. They will have a ceremony around the war memorial in the village, after which there will be a mad dash to the bar for drinks , courtesy of the Mayor.


This year, as the 11th falls on a Sunday we wont be in the village, but will have the ceremony at our Anglican church , with wreath laying, and all the somehow comforting words. My husband is reading the Act of Remembrance which ends with the immortal words...

'Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn. '

At the going down of the sun and in the morning

We will remember them'.


Watching some of the first world war very old soldiers the other evening I was sad to think that our children and grandchildren will never have that same knowledge that we who were alive in the war years have. Glad also that hopefully they will never know another world war, but sad because I'm not sure if young people have any concept of the lives that were thrown away in that terrible time. Though I do remember my grandchildren being very moved by a school visit to the 2nd World War beaches. I know we teach 'War' in schools, but is it the same?


Tell me, do your children and grandchildren understand the sacrifices?

16 comments:

  1. I don't know what they teach in schools these days but I can't remember ever having a remembrance service when I was at school, I suppose the 2nd WW was still quite fresh then though.
    I think perhaps it's an age thing. I think once you've got a few years behind you and have had your own children the futile loss of life becomes more and more accute.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Quite impossible to know. My grandfather was in WWI - on the Somme. He survived the first day - one of 7 officers out of 37 and on the second day received a bullet through the shoulder, which, in effect, saved his life. He would never talk about his experiences, though I remember asking him frequently out of childish curiosity. I guess it was all just too hellish.

    ReplyDelete
  3. We used to show students a very moving documentary about the first world war called 'Lions Led By Donkeys'. It made me cry everytime but some students would look at me in amazement.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I would tell C if i could, as i feel its important for our children to know our history.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You know, at some level he might understand. He knows what violence is, he has suffered too.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My ex's father (passed a few years ago) fought throughout the 2nd World War and saw many of his friends blown up and "murdered". He met his wife during the war and says that although those years were the most devastating of his life, they brought happiness beyond his wildest dreams. He was a truly lovely man. As for our generation knowing the sacrifices, I am afraid I hold my hands up. At 37 I can not possibly say that I understand what these men and women (and children) went through.

    Crystal xx

    ReplyDelete
  7. But how could you, Crystal? However, you understand that it was dreadful.
    What worries me is that the new generation simply wont even be interested enough to understand.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My children now in their twenties are both interested and moved. Let us hope in some way the remembrance continues.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm not sure my little one or his friends can really yet understand the concept of death and war, and I guess it's instinctive to try to shield them from these things for as long as possible. They do certainly study WW2 on the British curriculum, although they seem to concentrate on things such as ration books and buildings getting bombed and how life was for their grandparents at that time. It's a hard thing to explain, and as others have said, understanding of these events and their context dawns gradually over the years.

    ReplyDelete
  10. My granddaughters in primary school are taught about World War II, it's part of the National Curriculum but I fear they are not taught the reality of WAR. I get a bit incensed about it actually so was interested to read your blog and see your question. There have been some good programmes on TV this weekend, a couple with Ian Hislop and also the Paxman one on Wilfred Owen. They are the sort of things we should be showing the younger generation I think. Also hear the truth from soldiers who have been to war, though often their experiences are so painful they cannot speak about it. Less glorification is what is needed. I have blogged today on Remembrance, poems written by poets of all nations.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My littlest is too young, she just loves a day when she gets to wear a pretty red flower. My boy, nearly 9, is in many ways too young to properly understand, but we tell him stories of his great grandad and great great grandads who fought in WW1, and my parents tell him stories of the second war. Naturally he is interested in air raids and victories anD gas asks, but we took him to church yesterday, and we talk about what the silence means, and how very frightened children must be today who live in war zones. I think it slowly sinks in, and I also think it has a lot to do with age - to die at, say, 25, doesn't seem such a shocking waste to a teenager. It's all unthinkable to me now.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've spent this afternoon with a lovely gent called Ralph.Ralph is 87 years old and is history on legs. He loves to recall and describe his experiences during WW 2. I wish he'd write his experiences down, as it certainly makes it all seem very real. He's a lovely chap and has a lovely sense of humour. Although he did become very sad when he spoke about his "pals" who never lived to see the end of the war.

    ReplyDelete
  13. A very thought-provoking blog Elizabeth. I always feel so moved by the Remembrance Day service. Our children grow more interested with age and both Dave and I have been very involved in teaching war literature in schools which provides a chance to explore the issues surrounding such times. I hope this makes the children think and relate the things discussed to the many senseless wars still going on today xx

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'm glad that in France the ceremonies to remember the November armistice and 8 May are completely secular, instead of mixing up religion and history. It feels purer here; more honest.

    ReplyDelete
  15. It's still taught here - fewer veterens living each year, but the memory is kept alive. Children know about the incredible sacrifices of the men at Vimy and the Newfoundlanders in the nearby Beaumont Hamel and then later in Normandy and the far east. Too too sad.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Contact these guys and become one of the folk who collect the dosh and give out the little bluets
    http://www.defense.gouv.fr/onac/content/download/92632/822397/file/depliant%20collecteur%202007.pdf

    That's a hell of a URL, you'll have to copy and paste it probably.

    We also collect for bluets on May 8th to celebrate the end of the 39-45 war

    ReplyDelete

I love to read your comments. Thank you for visiting me.